Amelia - Movie Review of the Amelia Earhart Movie Starring Hillary Swank

74

By Dolores Monet

Amelia Earheart

(wikimedia commons)
See all 3 photos
(wikimedia commons)


Amelia is the Mira Nair's latest movie and stars Hillary Swank as the famous aviatrix, Amelia Earhart. Amelia follows Earhart from 1928 to her disappearance somewhere over the Pacific Ocean during her attempt to be the first pilot to circumnavigate the globe. The search mounted for the lost Amelia and her navigator, Fred Noonan (Christopher Eccleston) was the greatest search ever undertaken.

Let me start off by telling you that I love Amelia Earhart and have ever since I was a little girl swept away by Amelia's daring, her lanky boyish beauty, and, of course, the mystery of her famous disappearance 72 years ago.

So, I went into the theatre with great expectations. I left with mixed feelings.

Finding Amelia: The True Story of the Earheart Disappearance
Amazon Price: $18.95
Forum Amelia Earhart Instant Disguise Kit
Amazon Price: $7.82
List Price: $9.99
Amelia
Amazon Price: $11.99
List Price: $17.98

From the moment Hillary Swank appeared on the screen on the wing of a plane that perfectly mimicked a well-known photograph, tears bubbled up in my eyes. Hillary Swank was Amelia Earhart. That oh-so memorable face, the hesitant yet luminous smile, the smattering of freckles like angel kisses, her movements, the quick shift from shyness to bravado, from humility to daring-do. She was the perfect androgynous Amelia. Plus she wore those cool jumpsuits.



Amelia Earhart

Amelia was partially based on the book East to the Dawn

East to the Dawn: The Life of Amelia Earhart
Amazon Price: $1.29
List Price: $15.95
East to the Dawn: The Life of Amelia Earhart
Amazon Price: $15.95

However.

The movie never seems to really get off the ground. Choppy scenes come off as a montage rather than a dramatic sequence. Amelia comes plopped into fame as if she was born to it. Forget her family (except for a few brief mentions). Forget her early years and how Amelia Earhart, the social worker came to be the most famous flying lady ever to grace the cockpit of an airplane.

Richard Gere plays Amelia's husband and promoter, George Putnam, a mature gentleman who seems unsure whether he speaks in a New England accent or not. The handsome Gere often spoils his looks by smiling, transforming himself to a bunny rabbit. Amelia's lover, Gene Vidal (father of Gore Vidal) is played by a flat, charmless Ewan McGregor.with greasy hair to typify the time. There is a moment with Eleanor Roosevelt that could have been heartwarming if the actress who played Eleanor had attempted to come even close to that familiar voice.

And the choppy scenes continued. It started to get on my nerves. I began to be thankful that I had not paid actual money to watch Amelia. I would have been shocked to realize that Mira Nair had made one of my all time favorite movies, 'Monsoon Wedding.'

But

Just as in real life, or the life of Amelia Earhart I'd wish to be depicted on the big screen, Amelia only came alive when planes were involved. Amelia looked uncomfortable on land as a beached mermaid. Stilted dialogue did not help.

But when the plane soared over the waves and into the clouds, or when Amelia waved her stiff wave as she climbed into the cockpit of the ill fated Electra - Amelia lived. She stares blankly into the camera, then a smile flickers on her golden face and Hillary won my heart. There was Amelia in that red checked shirt, in the familiar scarves I recalled  from all those long ago pictures.

And as a movie must convince us that we live in the moment, my foolish heart willed Amelia Earhart to circumnavigate the globe. Maybe this time. I counted down the miles as she left Miami for her east to west flight on one of the 20th century's greatest quests. I almost believed that she could make it.

Amelia Earhart's Shoes: Is the Mystery Solved?
Amazon Price: $13.99
List Price: $23.95
Amelia Earhart
Amazon Price: $15.00
Amelia Earhart's Shoes: Is the Mystery Solved? [Paperback]
Amazon Price: $148.66

Amelia Trailer

Comments

Misstikal1 profile image

Misstikal1 2 years ago

This is an awesome post. Keep up the good work.

Please be a friend and visit me at:

http://hubpages.com/hub/Life-As-It-Really-Is

http://hubpages.com/hub/5-Ways-To-Help-Keep-Your-L

http://hubpages.com/hub/beyondlife

topsecret profile image

topsecret 2 years ago

AMELIA is BIG news in Atchison KS. The movie may NOT tell the real story, but another story of Amelia is unfolding at: http://hubpages.com/t/e3acc

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet Hub Author 2 years ago

Miss - glad that you enjoyed it! Thanks for commenting. I always check out folks who visit my hubs.

topsecret - As I said to Miss, I always return a visit. Looking forward to reading your Amelia hub. Of course, I know there are some very weird stores about her disappearance (you just can't get away from those reptilian shape shifter stories these days).

habee profile image

habee 2 years ago

Wow, can't wait to see this!

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet Hub Author 2 years ago

habee - I enjoyed it even though it wasn't the best movie I ever saw and they could have done a way better job, I just loved watching Hilary Swank look like Amelia Earhart. Thanks for commenting, habee!

Cheeky Girl profile image

Cheeky Girl Level 4 Commenter 2 years ago

Amelia is a great story and a great and inspiring woman! There was the rumour that she was spying for the U.S. Government, but I guess we'll be debating that forever. I am looking forward to seeing the movie here! Nice Hub!

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet Hub Author 2 years ago

Cheeky - some of the stories and debates are sure interesting. I even heard one where they claim that Amelia was taken up by aliens from outer space. (sigh) She was a popular, though already disappeared figure when I was a girl, and was quite the inspiration despite her sad end.

TheMonk profile image

TheMonk 10 months ago

I got that movie DVD as a present from a friend. I was debating whether I would get another DVD in exchange for this one, or if I would just keep it. You made me keep it. Great film!

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet Hub Author 10 months ago

TheMonk - it is a great story and Hillary did look the part. Not the best movie but I did enjoy it. Thanks1

J Burgraff profile image

J Burgraff Level 3 Commenter 9 months ago

I enjoyed the hub a great deal and am happy to find out that you are a fan of Amelia Earhart as am I. I'm going to have to watch the movie because I love Hilary Swank and I too, think she looks just like Amelia.

Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet Hub Author 8 months ago

J - Oh, she did and some of the scenes were exact duplicates of some of the old photographs. My only criticism is that I did not burst into tears at the end. The fact that I did not means they missed something.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working